Family 01

The Carfagna's Story

Family Traditions Since 1937

Our family’s story in America began when our great-grandfather Saturnino Carfagna emigrated to the United States in 1919 and was given the name “Sam” by officials at Ellis Island.

From there, he worked as a laborer in three two-year stints, returning a few times to his home in the Abruzzo-Molise region of Italy. In 1925, Sam made enough money to allow his wife, Nonna Maria, his three children, and his mother-in-law to move to the United States, settling on a farm in New Albany, Ohio.

Sam established the first Carfagna’s store in the Linden neighborhood of Columbus, Ohio, on Cleveland Avenue in 1937. Not long after, the store gained a reputation for its quality meats, Italian deli, groceries, and outstanding service. Saturnino often said, “Give our customers what they want, not what you want.” His business success was due to his innate business sense, kindness, keen sensitivity to customer needs and wants, and his strict demand for selling quality products.

Family 2

The Grandsons Honor The Family Traditions

Today, Saturnino’s grandsons Dino and Sam are charged with growing and overseeing all aspects of the Carfagna’s business, with the entire family’s help down to the grandchildren. Following Sam’s footsteps, the grandsons started Carfagna’s catering business and in-store prepared foods. It was here where they resurrected many of the family recipes with which they had grown and loved so much.

Family 3


It was the advice of their grandfather that led Dino and Sam to the all-new Carfagna’s Market & Ristorante. Taking the next step to fulfill the customers’ wants, Dino and Sam brought Central Ohio an immersive Italian experience like no other. Located at 1440 Gemini Place, this 28,000 sq ft location combines their Market, Butcher shop, Wine Shop, and Restaurant all under one roof. Now, customers can watch their Italian specialties like pasta, cookies, cannoli, and fresh mozzarella made right before their eyes!

Now, along with Dino’s wife, Terri, Sam’s wife, Jeannene, and their children, the 4th generation of Carfagnas is ready to take the next step in living those words of wisdom spoken by Great Grandpa Sam. In doing so, the Carfagna family will keep the traditions, values, and service for which they have become famous alive for years to come.alive for years to come.

View our products
by category

“Use Only the Very Best and Finest Ingredients and Never, Never Rush.”
- Our Grandmother, Nonna Maria

Experience Joy In
Carfagna's Events

Immerse yourself in the traditions of Italy by joining the Carfagna family at one of our many events. We regularly offer classes and demos where you can learn Italian, master new recipes, or brush up on your skills.

Have no product in the cart!