Shop the Taste of Italy!
  • Organic Original Recipe Pasta Sauce
    Our Original Recipe Pasta Sauce made with 100% organic ingredients. For the health conscious, clean eaters and the curious! While all of our sauces are made using 100% natural ingredients, this one goes a step further!
  • Meat Lover’s Trio!
    All three of our Meat Lover’s Series pasta sauces. Butcher’s Blend Ground Beef, Savory Italian Sausage, and Little Meatballs! Can’t decide which meat sauce to buy? Buy all 3 sauces together and save $  
  • Meat Lover’s Little Meatballs Pasta Sauce
    This little meatball meat sauce is part of our trio of sauces in the Meat Lover’s Series.  We take our yummy little “wedding soup” meatballs and pack them into this can’t miss sauce. Slow cooked in our original recipe sauce, the Little Meatball sauce is as delicious as it is…
  • Meat Lover’s Savory Italian Sausage Pasta Sauce
    This Italian sausage meat sauce is part of our trio of sauces in the Meat Lover’s Series. Big chunks of Italian sausage kick up the flavor in this pasta sauce. Our original recipe marinara slow cooked with flavorful Italian sausage… need we say more?
  • Original Gourmet Pasta Sauce
    Extra thick, crushed tomatoes, olive oil and chianti wine. This is it! Exceptional, second to none. This family recipe sets the bar for high quality Italian cooking. One full quart – 32 ozs. – 947 ml
  • Homemade Vodka Sauce
    Creamy, Cheesy, Tomatoey. Very rich. Made with fresh real cream. One full quart 32 ozs. – 947 ml.
  • Pootaneska Sauce
    Spicy tomato filets, garlic, and black olives. This is spicy hot! Just like southern Italy. One full quart – 32 ozs. – 947 ml.
  • The Sicilian
    Baby portabella mushrooms and roasted peppers. Excellent served over cut pastas, such as Penne or Rigatoni. One full quart – 32 ozs. – 947 ml.
  • Pomodoro Basilico
    Tomato filets, Garlic, and Basil. Authentic homeland recipe. Same sauce you will experience in Italy today. One full quart – 32 ozs. – 947 ml.
  • Pizza Sauce
    A rich red sauce that adds homemade richness and flavor to any pizza. One full pint – 16 ozs. – 473 ml.
  • White Balsamic and Marinade
    Great on Green Leafy Salads, Pasta Salads, and Subs. Excellent as a marinade for chicken and pork 16 fl. ozs. – 437 ml.
Carfagna's Market logo


A local Italian family tradition since 1937. When it comes to authentic Italian food in Central Ohio it’s Carfagna’s. For over 80 years Carfagna’s has been the standout in the local Italian food scene. The Carfagna family is dedicated to keeping the traditions, values, and service for which we’ve become famous alive for years to come.

Be Sure to Check Out Our Other Sites

Stay Connected


Subscribe to Our Free Newsletter

Click here to stay up-to-date on wine and beer tastings, special events at Carfagna's and all things wine and food!

Have no product in the cart!