• Extra Virgin Novello Olive Oil – PRE-ORDER EXCLUSIVE
    Extra Virgin Novello Olive Oil – PRE-ORDER EXCLUSIVE
    $39.00
      A once-per-year opportunity to taste olive oil straight from the press! Produced by Olio Guglielmi   This medium robust intensity Extra Virgin Novello Olive Oil produced from green Coratina Continue Reading
  • Whiskey & Cigar Dinner, 8.15.24
    $75.00
    Our Inaugural Whiskey & Cigar Dinner! This FUN event will be hosted by 'Whiskey Pete' Ambassador for Brown-Foreman, and our own Nate, Cigar Geek for Carfagna's. The Event will feature 3 Cigars, a Specialty cocktail and 4 Whiskeys paired with Food!
  • Summer Pleasures… Wine & Cheese Pairing, 7.30.24
    $59.00
    The Second Season of Wine & Cheese Pairings begin.  This season we’ll feature 4 Wine & Cheese Pairing through the rest of 2024! Wine & Cheese Pairing will be presented Continue Reading
  • New West Coast Wines Tasting,7.20.24
    $49.00
    New West Coast Wine Tasting...  4 tables with 5 Wines each. Antipasto Tray, Hot Appetizers & Pizzas!
  • Original Gourmet Pasta Sauce
    $7.59$22.77
    Extra thick, traditional style marinara sauce. This is it! Exceptional, second to none. This family recipe sets the bar for high quality Italian cooking. One full quart – 32 ozs. Continue Reading
  • Homemade Vodka Sauce
    $7.59$22.77
    Creamy, Cheesy, Tomatoey. Very rich. Made with fresh real cream. One full quart 32 ozs. – 947 ml. Now available in a 3-Pack! buy in sets of 3 to save Continue Reading
  • Pomodoro Basilico
    $7.59$22.77
    Tomato filets, Garlic, and Basil. Authentic homeland recipe. Same sauce you will experience in Italy today. One full quart – 32 ozs. – 947 ml. Now available in a 3-Pack! Continue Reading
  • The Sicilian
    $7.59$22.77
    Baby portabella mushrooms and roasted peppers. Excellent served over cut pastas, such as Penne or Rigatoni. One full quart – 32 ozs. – 947 ml. Now available in a 3-Pack! Continue Reading
  • Pootaneska Sauce
    $7.59$22.77
    Spicy tomato filets, garlic, and black olives. This is spicy hot! Just like southern Italy. One full quart – 32 ozs. – 947 ml. Now available in a 3-Pack! buy Continue Reading
  • Meat Lover’s Savory Italian Sausage Pasta Sauce
    $8.99$26.97
    This Italian sausage meat sauce is part of our trio of sauces in the Meat Lover’s Series. Big chunks of Italian sausage kick up the flavor in this pasta sauce. Continue Reading
  • Meat Lover’s Little Meatballs Pasta Sauce
    $8.99$26.79
    This little meatball meat sauce is part of our trio of sauces in the Meat Lover’s Series.  We take our yummy little “wedding soup” meatballs and pack them into this Continue Reading
  • Meat Lover’s Trio!
    $25.77
    All three of our Meat Lover’s Series pasta sauces. Butcher’s Blend Ground Beef, Savory Italian Sausage, and Little Meatballs! Can’t decide which meat sauce to buy? Buy all 3 sauces Continue Reading
  • Organic Original Recipe Pasta Sauce
    Organic Original Recipe Pasta Sauce
    $7.99$23.97
    Our Original Recipe Pasta Sauce made with 100% organic ingredients. For the health conscious, clean eaters and the curious! While all of our sauces are made using 100% natural ingredients, Continue Reading
  • Pizza Sauce
    $4.99
    A rich red sauce that adds homemade richness and flavor to any pizza. One full pint – 16 ozs. – 473 ml.
  • Creamy Italian Dressing
    $6.99
    Our Non-Dairy, Creamy Italian Dressing. White Balsamic Vinegar, Olive Oil and Italian Seasonings! Great on Green Leafy Salads, Pasta Salads, and Subs. Excellent as a marinade for chicken and pork Continue Reading
  • White Balsamic Dressing and Marinade
    White Balsamic Dressing and Marinade
    $6.99
    White Balsamic Vinaigrette Dressing. White balsamic vinegar, olive oil and Italian seasonings. Simple and delicious! This is our popular house dressing at our restaurant. Great on Green Leafy Salads, Pasta Continue Reading
  • Chili Ready Spicy
    $7.99$23.97
    Our very own chili starter sauce! Want quick and easy chili? Brown 1 lb of your favorite chili meat or vegetables and add 1 jar of our Chili Ready sauce Continue Reading
  • Chili Ready Mild
    $7.99$23.97
    Our very own chili starter sauce! Want quick and easy chili? Brown 1 lb of your favorite chili meat or vegetables and add 1 jar of our Chili Ready sauce Continue Reading
  • BBQ Sauce
    $6.99
    A rich, hearty BBQ sauce. One full pint – 16 ozs. – 473 ml.
  • photo of steaks
    #1, 10 Beef Loin Steaks Box
    $129.00
    2, 8oz, Delmonico Steaks 2, 14oz, Ribeyes Steaks 2, 8oz, New York Strip Steaks 2, 14oz, T-Bone Steaks 2, 7oz, Filet Mignon Steaks Give a gift that your family and Continue Reading
  • photo of steaks
    #2, “Big Steak” Lovers Box
    $119.00
    2, 16oz, Porterhouse Steaks 2, 14oz, Ribeyes Steaks 2, 8oz, Delmonico Steaks 2, 14oz, T-Bone Steaks Give a gift that your family and friends will truly appreciate and enjoy! When Continue Reading
  • photo of steaks
    #3, Four New York Strips & Four Filets Box
    $109.00
    4, 8oz, New York Strip Steaks 4, 7oz, Filet Mignon Steaks Give a gift that your family and friends will truly appreciate and enjoy! When you care enough to give Continue Reading
  • photo of steak
    #4, I Really Love New York Box
    $119.00
    10, 8oz, New York Strip Steaks Give a gift that your family and friends will truly appreciate and enjoy! When you care enough to give the very best… give a Continue Reading
  • photo of steak and lobster tail
    #5, Surf & Turf Box
    $149.00
    4, 7oz, Filet Mignon Steaks 4, 6oz, Lobster Tails Give a gift that your family and friends will truly appreciate and enjoy! When you care enough to give the very Continue Reading
  • photo of steak wine and candy box
    #6, That’s Amore Box
    $69.00
    2, 7oz, Filet Mignon Steaks 1 Bottle of Prosecco Wine 1 Box of Torrone Candy Give a gift that your family and friends will truly appreciate and enjoy! When you Continue Reading
  • photo of steak
    #7, Totally Filets Box
    $89.00
    6, 7oz, Filet Mignon Steaks Give a gift that your family and friends will truly appreciate and enjoy! When you care enough to give the very best… give a Carfagna’s Continue Reading
  • Photo of steaks
    #8, Delmonicos & New York Strips Box
    $79.00
    3, 8oz, Delmonico Steaks 3, 8oz, New York Strip Steaks Give a gift that your family and friends will truly appreciate and enjoy! When you care enough to give the Continue Reading
  • photo of steak
    #9, Our Biggest Filet Box
    $139.00
    10, 7oz, Filet Mignon Steaks Give a gift that your family and friends will truly appreciate and enjoy! When you care enough to give the very best… give a Carfagna’s Continue Reading
  • photo of red wine and steak
    #10, Four Filets & Wine Box
    $79.00
    4, 7oz, Filet Mignon Steaks 1 Bottle of Carfagna’s Wine Your Choice Red or White The Carfagna’s red wine is an Italian Blend with grapes from Sardegna, Italy. It is Continue Reading
  • #11, New York Strips & Filets Box
    $65.00
    2, 7oz, Filet Mignon Steaks 2, 8oz, New York Strip Steaks Give a gift that your family and friends will truly appreciate and enjoy! When you care enough to give Continue Reading
  • #12, I Love New York Box
    $59.00
    4, 8oz, New York Strip Steaks Give a gift that your family and friends will truly appreciate and enjoy! When you care enough to give the very best… give a Continue Reading
  • photo of red wine and steak
    #13, Two Filets & Wine Box
    $59.00
    2, 7oz, Filet Mignon Steaks 1 Bottle of Carfagna’s Wine Your Choice Red or White The Carfagna’s red wine is an Italian Blend with grapes from Sardegna, Italy. It is Continue Reading
  • photo of wine and steaks
    #15, Steaks & Wine Box
    $89.00
    2, 7oz, Filet Mignon Steaks 2, 8oz, Delmonico Steaks 2, 8oz, New York Strip Steaks 1 Bottle of Carfagna’s Wine Your Choice Red or White The Carfagna’s red wine is Continue Reading
  • photo of ground beef
    Family Value: Ground Beef Freezer Special
    $219.00
    50 –  1# pkgs of Ground Beef 50 Total Pounds Our Own Proprietary Blend Ground In House Daily USDA Choice or Prime Beef Trimmings PICK UP ONLY – IN STORE Continue Reading
  • Photo for Carfagna's family value packages
    Family Value Box #8: No Chicken Little!
    $179.00
    4 CUT UP CHICKENS 5 pkgs (2 EA) BONE-IN SPLIT CHICKEN BREAST 4 pkgs (1 LB) CHICKEN TENDERS 5 pkgs (2 EA) BNLS CHICKEN BREAST 5 pkgs (1 LB) CUT Continue Reading
  • Photo for Carfagna's family value packages
    Family Value Box #11: Couples Stocked Freezer
    $199.00
    4 NEW YORK STRIP STEAKS 4 BACON WRAPPED FILET MIGNON 2 pkgs (2 EA) PORK CHOPS 2 pkgs (1 LB) BRATWURST SAUSAGE 2 pkgs (2 EA) STEAK BURGERS 2 pkgs Continue Reading
  • Photo for Carfagna's family value packages
    Family Value Box #12: Small Family Value Box
    $189.00
    4 T-BONE STEAKS 4 NEW YORK STRIP STEAKS 4 BNLS SIRLOIN STEAKS 4 pkgs (1 LB) GROUND BEEF  2 pkgs (1 LB) SLICED BACON  2 pkgs (2 EA) BONE-IN SPLIT Continue Reading
  • Photo for Carfagna's family value packages
    Family Value Box #13: Stocked Freezer!
    $359.00
    3 CARFAGNA’S PEPPERONI PIZZAS 3 (EA) 6 MEATBALLS IN SAUCE 3 (EA) 26oz SPAGHETTI SAUCE 1 HALF TRAY MEAT & CHEESE LASAGNA 3 pkgs (1 LB) ITALIAN SAUSAGE 6 BACON Continue Reading
  • Photo for Carfagna's family value packages
    Family Value Box #21: Great Grilling Value
    $349.00
    8 BNLS SIRLOIN STEAKS 8 RIBEYE STEAKS 8 NEW YORK STRIP STEAKS 2 SLABS SPARE RIBS 3 pkgs (1 LB) ITALIAN SAUSAGE 3 pkgs (1 LB) BRATWURST SAUSAGE 20 (1/4 Continue Reading
  • Photo for Carfagna's family value packages
    Family Value Box #25: The Grill Special!
    $199.00
    10 NEW YORK STRIP STEAKS 5 pkgs (2 EA) STEAK BURGERS 5 pkgs (2 EA) PORK CHOPS  5 pkgs (2 EA) BNLS CHICKEN BREAST 2 pkgs (1 LB) BRATWURST SAUSAGE  Continue Reading
  • Photo for Carfagna's family value packages
    Family Value Box #26: The Hearty Value
    $179.00
    3 LB TOP ROUND RUMP ROAST 3 LB BNLS CHUCK ROAST 2 LB BNLS PORK LOIN ROAST 3 pkgs (1 LB) CHICKEN TENDERS 3 CUT UP CHICKENS 3 pkgs (2 Continue Reading
  • Photo for Carfagna's family value packages
    Family Value Box #27: Couples Grill Value
    $139.00
    4 NEW YORK STRIP STEAKS 4 BACON WRAPPED FILET MIGNON 2 pkgs (2 EA) PORK CHOPS 2 pkgs (1 LB) BRATWURST SAUSAGE 2 pkgs (2 EA) STEAK BURGERS 2 pkgs Continue Reading
  • Photo for Carfagna's family value packages
    Family Value Box #30: Variety Value Box
    $219.00
    4 NEW YORK STRIP STEAKS 4 BACON WRAPPED FILET MIGNON 4 pkgs (2 EA) PORK CHOPS 4 pkgs (2 EA) STEAK BURGERS 2 CARFAGNA’S PEPPERONI PIZZAS 2 pkgs (1 LB) Continue Reading
  • Photo for Carfagna's family value packages
    Family Value Box #36: Steaks & Chops
    $199.00
    10 BONELESS RIBEYE STEAKS 5 T-BONE STEAKS  3 pkgs (2 ea) BEEF CUBE STEAKS 3 pkgs (2 ea) BEEF STEAK BURGERS 3 (1 lb) BRATWURST SAUSAGE 3 pkgs (2 ea) Continue Reading
  • GRILLERS VALUE BUNDLE
    GRILLERS VALUE BUNDLE
    $139.00
    The Grillers Value Box features our most popular items for those who love to fire up the grill! 6 – ITALIAN FESTIVAL SAUSAGES 6 – BEER BRATS 8 – STEAK Continue Reading
  • CARFAGNA’S FAVORITES BUNDLE
    CARFAGNA’S FAVORITES BUNDLE
    $159.00
    The Carfagna’s Favorites Box features a variety of the most popular items from our market! 4 – BACON WRAPPED FILETS – 7 oz each 4 – DELMONICO’S (boneless ribeye) – Continue Reading
  • MADE IN HOUSE SAUSAGE BUNDLE
    MADE IN HOUSE SAUSAGE BUNDLE
    $99.00
    Select the Sausage you’d like or pick our Variety Box to try all three of our most popular made in house sausages. 36 sausages per box! Festival Sausage: Our signature Continue Reading
  • STEAK BUNDLE
    STEAK BUNDLE
    $199.00
    The Steak Bundle features our most popular steaks! 4 – NY STRIP STEAKS 4 – BACON WRAPPED FILETS 4 – DELMONICO’S (boneless ribeye) 2 – PORTERHOUSES 2 – RIBEYES   Continue Reading
  • COUPLE’S VARIETY BUNDLE
    COUPLE’S VARIETY BUNDLE
    $159.00
    The Couple’s Variety Box features our favorites for couples and small families! 4 – NY STRIP STEAKS 4 – BACON WRAPPED FILETS 4 – BONE-IN PORK CHOPS 6 – BEER Continue Reading
  • Carfagna’s Gift Card : IN-STORE USE ONLY
    $27.00$102.00
    Please Note: There is a $2.00 postage fee added to the purchase price of each gift card. This Gift Card is for in-store & restaurant use only. You, or your Continue Reading
  • Carfagna’s Cooking Class Voucher
    $102.13
    Carfagna’s Cooking Class Voucher is an eGift Card to send the gift of a Cooking Class. Each voucher will cover the cost (plus tax) for 1 guest. They may sign Continue Reading
  • Carfagna’s Online Gift Voucher
    $25.00$100.00
    Carfagna’s Online Voucher is an eGift Card for use in our online store. You will not be able to use this in-store at our market & restaurant. If you would Continue Reading
  • Holiday Beef Tenderloin Roast Kit
    $159.00
    Carfagna’s All-In-One Beef Tenderloin Roasting Kit!  With all the ingredients and roasting pan included, we’ve designed a kit to make your Holiday Roast as easy as 1, 2, 3! season Continue Reading
  • gift basket photo
    The Paesano Gift Basket
    $49.00$89.00
    2, 16oz Carfagna’s Pasta Sauce 2 lbs Pasta $10 Carfagna’s Gift Card All for Just $49 (or two for $89) Give a gift people will truly appreciate and enjoy! Fine Continue Reading
  • Carfagna's gift basket photo
    Il Toscano Gift Basket
    $99.00
    2 Carfagna Pasta Sauces Imported Pastas 2 Italian Cheeses Dried Salami Olive Oil Breadsticks Cookies Il Toscano Gift Basket Only $99 Give a gift people will truly appreciate and enjoy! Continue Reading
  • Carfagna's gift basket photo
    The Italian Fireside Gift Basket
    $129.00
    1 Red Wine – Italian Blend with grapes from Sardegna, Italy 1 White Wine – Pinot Grigio with grapes from Veneto, Italy 2 Cheeses 2 Carfagna’s Pasta Sauce Pasta Olives Continue Reading
  • Carfagna's gift basket photo
    The Veni, Vidi, Vici Gift Basket
    $179.00
    1 Red Wine – Italian Red Blend with grapes from Sardegna, Italy 1 White Wine – Pinot Grigio with grapes from Veneto, Italy 4 Cheeses 4 boxes of Crackers Breadsticks Continue Reading
Have no product in the cart!
0